Showing posts with label digital. Show all posts
Showing posts with label digital. Show all posts

Thursday, 26 November 2015

Slides and learning

Thoughts provoked by: "To provide or not to provide course PowerPoint slides? The impact of instructor-provided slides upon student attendance and performance"

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360131515000433

A link to this article was recently posted in Twitter the day after I tried to add an Apple Keynote slide-show to the VLE for my online work-based undergraduate course for the first time in 17 years.

Firstly I was rather suspicious of the pedagogy given the use of "instructor provided' in the title. After reading the article it does sound like the slides they were talking about were used in the chalk and talk type approach with tutor instructing rather than facilitating learning. 

One of the problems seems to be tutors worried about sharing their resources with students. I thought that concern had disappeared long ago; open access gifting information to students and beyond seems a far better way to spread knowledge than exposing resources only during a lecture. I can't see why a competent tutor would want to restrict access to knowledge unless they are sharing information about research that is still in progress, is not fully verified and that they have not yet formally published or other information that has strong ethical or commercial reasons for confidentiality to be maintained. 

The article does not discuss slide-show design in much detail, reading between the lines there were either the poor practice type slides where a tutor reads loads of text, and often bullet points, off each slide while students try and absorb content while scribbling notes. There were some trials of more minimalist slides and slides with missing information. 

I did not see any reference to using media in the slides - an audio track with each slide and only key words, phrases or images on the visual part of the slide is a good strategy Lot's of folk seem to treat this kind of presentation software akin to chalk on a blackboard or the old acetate OHP approach where a visual element accompanies a talk about the visual content. 


Slide-show apps are presentation software; don't treat them as visual content display software. 

 Should a lecture really just be tutor talking to students about stuff on a screen with students then missing some of what is said while scribbling notes during the event? Seeing reams of text on screen, hearing it read out while simultaneously having to take notes about it is not a great pedagogical approach. I meet that approach time and time again in conferences I have to pay a lot of money to attend.

An audio track for each slide can mean that the dominant content is not the visual element. All sorts of media can be embedded, the one I will use this Saturday is only the second ever slide-show I have made, it has a short embedded video clip of a resource I will talk about, the post event version will have an audio explanation to accompany each slide.

Slides with audio or video from the tutor that are posted in a VLE can be opened then paused and replayed so allowing students to take more detailed notes and to check that their notes are accurate. Hearing the vocal cues in a tutors voice helps interpret conviction, uncertainty, and many other aspects that are not always clear in a text only resource.

Most universities now have some sort of digital learning environment with discussion tools often referred to as a Virtual Learning Environment - I think Digital Learning Environment or Online Learning Environment would be better as it is a very real place where real learning takes place, perhaps the "Virtual" element subliminally reduces perceptions about the potential value, however that is another argument for another post.

Using the 'VLE" rather than slide-shows during a lecture can be a useful way to increase student engagement in the VLE . Lectures are a very small amount of their learning time compared with the hours tagged for autonomous student led learning. A typical undergraduate 30 credit module might have 40 hours of tutor managed learning and 260 hours of independent study. If tutors can develop habits where students spend some of their independent study time in the VLE, and encourage the gift society kind of ethos, we have the chance of developing strong communities of practice. The sharing of professional/scholarly social media or website sources and good literature finds along with peer discussion about those and peer review of draft work can provoke deeper learning and trust and bonding within student groups. 

 Is it not better for students to do preparatory work in advance and to then be able to contribute to the lecture in which the tutor can then engage in academic / scholarly discussion about what they have learned, what sense making they are doing and what meaning they are constructing? Perhaps the term "lecture" needs to be committed to the archives of history as it does provoke perceptions about instructional gatekeeper of knowledge approaches.

Slide-shows that explain learning activities linked to assignment learning outcomes and provide links to published papers or online social media, websites, embedded YouTube or TED talks videos etc. can be useful if shared in advance with the expectation that students will access and review the content and be ready to discuss what they have uncovered/discovered during the subsequent lecture.

Lecture capture can avoid the distraction of note-taking during an event and enable deep focused concentration and interacting in the event. Students watching a video of a captured lecture retrospectively have time to make notes, to reflect on content and extend their conceptualisation of the learning. Such approaches can also help students understand good ways to make use of their independent study time. Students who do not deploy effective learning strategies during independent study time are unlikely to thrive.

I wonder whether it is the poor pedagogical practice that leads to weak learning rather than the use of a particular kind of software. I was about to say something about 'perhaps some innovative use of the software would help' but what I have discussed above is far from innovative it is just common sense. 

One problem I have to acknowledge is the time tutors have in which to work on preparation of resources. As education at all levels has been increasingly financially squeezed over the decades the potential of digital technologies has increased as has the expectations of the extent to which they are used. The relatively recent addition of a layer of email engagement on top of a working day with no extra time given in which to deal with it is a particular problem that that been well covered in publications re;eating to education and to the commercial sector. There is less time available to explore the potential of emerging and established digital tools and to create what is needed for delivering outstanding student experiences.

A timely Tweet was aimed at me from Steve Turnbull just as I published this post:




Steve went on to mention that when he started using slides he used lots of bullet points then realised why the audience looked bored. As I implied above - working out what not to do is just a matter of common sense, try something, reflect on it and improve.

A good how not to do slideshows video: 

A picky aside:
The article consistently uses "PPT" for the registered trade name 'PowerPoint®' I have little faith in peer reviewers and am not surprised they did not pick that one up, although I have to say I often leave the ® symbol off trade names in informal communications #blush.

https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/legal/intellectualproperty/trademarks/usage/general.aspx


"When referring to Microsoft software and products, apply the appropriate trademark symbols in accordance with the list of current Microsoft trademarks. View the Microsoft Trademarks list."


Worthington, D.L. and Levasseur, D.G.2015. To provide or not to provide course PowerPoint slides? The impact of instructor-provided slides upon student attendance and performance. Computers & Education.Volume 85, July 2015, Pages 14–22 [Online] Accessed 26 Nov. 2015

Wednesday, 15 July 2015

Fos day 2

Ye like with my day 1 blog I have written too much again but this is my learning journal so reflective notes for my benefit to help me think through what I have been doing and learning.

I spent a little more time in the FOS G+ community G+ still doesn't feel like a great place for hosting large communities, like with lots of things they can be fit for purpose but just don't attract some people and really work for others - Twitter is perhaps one of the best recentish examples of social network software that has the Marmite love it or hate it touch. I at first was not impressed but came to appreciate it over time, I have used G+ for many years and apart from the Hangouts it has never grown on me. That might be partly because of all the stuff that happens outside of what I would like to happen http://ii-learning.blogspot.co.uk/2015/07/g.html but is mostly just due to how it is organised.

The second chat was focused on flexible pedagogies with this as the core reading: https://www.heacademy.ac.uk/sites/default/files/resources/npi_report.pdf

I popped into the chat stream this morning to see what had been added since I left and James Clay had posted a link to his previous thoughts on informal learning - http://elearningstuff.net/tag/learning-spaces/  I agree with the thoughts about not being able to design informal learning, as soon design by a tutor or teacher creeps into in the real world the learning becomes formalised although that does depend on your conceptualisation of what formalised means. Discussions I have had over the last 18 years about this have tended to include reference to what happens in organisations in spaces such as around the water cooler or coffee area. Here conversation can be less formal and perhaps more spontaneous but I question how free that really is with the potential for a line manager to be round the corner or to arrive without being noticed - do people hold back? Does conversation tend to be more focused on gossip or moaning about colleagues or the organisation rather than learning from each other about stuff that is not directly related to accredited or work-focused, role-related learning?

One of the first online learning communities I joined included in its online design the provision of spaces for informal learning, it was hosted in FirstClass and included community folders tagged as the kinds of places people might hang out informally, there was a bar, a bus, a garden, a train, and more besides. It felt artificial and there was a lot of talk about e-moderating back then (Gilly Salmon style) so a suspicion that there would be some staff monitoring so it did not feel totally informal to some members although there was plenty of off topic discussion it mostly seemed to be social posturing and arranging liaisons. Today with more social spaces available I think it is better to suggest that students self organise in spaces that are tutor free/ Having discussed informal learning and made the suggestion I have been provided with insights into such spaces and they do seem to sometimes provoke strong bonding and valuable discussions. When the BA LTR course first started a small group of students did this on their own initiative and created  http://www.ultrastudents.co.uk/  more recently LTR cohorts have use G+ circles as informal spaces and I think there is some Facebook related interaction as well. Although the G+ spaces were informal the discussions seem to have often been very much focused on course related topics, I think the move might have been more related to dissatisfaction with the course discussion software limits on layout and tools rather than a need to escape tutors for informal learning. Several groups have then invited tutors into the spaces but that risked the whole course facilitation moving out of the institutional VLE and I was not keen on that fragmentation so suggested they post key points from their informal discussions into the VLE spaces.

We were asked to add an image that represented flexible pedagogies I had really struggled with that during the day and could only think of a blank canvas on which tutors and students could negotiate what and how they would learn in an equal partnership co-learning co-constructing. Given we are talking about flexible pedagogies for courses that was perhaps a step too far as negotiation would have to include topic and accreditation criteria. I would love to try that but I think perhaps a little too disruptive to gain institutional adoption. The notion of equality was questioned in the Twitter shower I think it rather came out of the rapidity of the discussion - equal in terms of mutual respect in this context as the tutor does hold the keys to what needs to be achieved and how that might be achieved within the framework of the institution so there is some hierarchy implicit.  n the time-limited pressure of a one hour chat I eventually hit on an old picture of a day with friends on Vilarrube beach near where we lived in Galicia. I wasn't impressed with myself but it served the purpose of stimulating my thinking about flexible pedagogies.

This kind of setting provides some materials, some structure, some limitations, but also adds some freedom in that adjacent to the castle that we had all set out to communally build were independently built structures such as dragons and cars, the boys can be seen in the distance starting to make a tunnel world -  their idea - dozens of holes linked by dozens of tunnels. Temperature was in the high 30s so forays into the sea were frequent. I guess that could equate to my needing breaks from study - diversions and mulling things over times to refresh the mind.

I have got a bit diverted into thinking about informal learning and identity, remembering just now about off topic discussions that developed integrated into the main online learning community discussions, I recall topics with stances being defended via vigorous evidence based debate such as creationism / evolution and the role of genetics and whether evolution can happen on a relatively rapid time-frame, particle physics and the possibilities of quantum computers - how will moving from binary to zero, one and 'simultaneous zero and one' affect calculating processes/power? Debate about single/multi-universe possibilities, discussions about cooking, health, keeping fit are just some of the seemingly spontaneous topics that come to mind and that fall into the informal learning category in my opinion. Some were spawned by course related topics such as discussing literature about reflective practice and flow theory leading to a chat about about the value of mulling critical incidents over when running or hill walking. All helped people learn, be that about how to express themselves and debate without causing or taking offence or how to find further information to bolster their arguments, or just how to have fun together with relative strangers who will not meet during a course.

I am more than happy for students and staff to chat about all sorts of things in the same space as their learning discussions, clear labelling of threads is important so those who want to can filter out what they do not want to be involved in. Sharing thoughts about what you are interested in helps convey identity, engaging in debates such as the creationism / evolution one also helps model good behaviour and critical friendship - debate the idea and accept difference rather than attacking it or getting angry about a person's stance. All very useful practice for engaging in course related critical peer review or debate.

One aspect that can limit flexibility is the mode of assessment, many institutions seem to have set processes for assessment that limit the product - submit a bound thesis, hand in an electronic file through something like Turnitin, post work in a community portal that picks certain things up as assessable, fill in an online quiz that is automatically marked there are many approaches and many of them impose limits; often text is to the forefront. One driver is reducing the time spent by markers, another is homogeneity so like is compared with like across a cohort. I had a discussion at the JISC connect more conference in Bristol and heard frustrated tutors complaining about the technological dog wagging the pedagogical tail - that is a situation that really limits pedagogy.

One of the aspects of the Ultraversity project I was very pleased to be associated with was the use of assessment by online portfolio. This amplifies how students can convey information both during the course of a module and at the point of assessment. There are very few restrictions as to what can be included, there is a limitation in that files have to be in the portfolio so can't be hosted online, this enables date stamping so ensures no changes are made after the submission date.  Assessors may not be able to install new software on their machines so access and interoperability is a key concern and addressed during semester to ensure that what is submitted can be assessed. File size can also be an issue although I have accepted portfolios that included single files of over 250Mb with agreement by prior negotiation that the creation of high resolution video was a work based competence so should be assessed in hi resolution format. There is no typical portfolio but over the three years a student might well have included at various times: Word, PDF, PowerPoint, Excel, various video formats, various audio formats, Prezi, screen shots of maps made using a range of concept mapping tools, Gant charts, animations, scanned paper sketches, electronic drawings, graphs and charts, images and posters, tables, diagrams, cartoons, Powtoons and more.

It was mentioned that institutions can be resistant to flexibility / innovation and I can't disagree but my experience at Anglia Ruskin has shown that they can also be willing to let people explore new approaches and to adopt some of what is learned into the mainstream. Economics are key to maintaining an institution and it is understandable that the new needs to be shown to have benefit before large scale investment can be directed along non -traditional vectors.

Since the chat I have also been thinking about what my online pedagogy is based on, I don't feel I can wear the badge of any specific learning theory, I am not an instructivist or constructivist, I don't really go for behaviourism and not keen on multiple intelligences and definitely not learning styles, I don't like dogma or didactic stances, I can't just accept 'truths' and don't see truths as permanent states or 'proof' or 'truth' as particularly useful concepts; proofs are limited by current strategies and often overthrown as time progresses understanding, 'truth' seems a dangerous concept that can limit thinking. I admired Alfred Korzybski and his idea in http://pialogue.info/books/Science-and-Sanity-Korzybski.pdf that the concept of 'is' is a limiting factor although it is a word that is hard to avoid using it should not be taken as meaning an absolute belief or state. When we say x is y we are only mapping our notion of what x might be; a map is not the territory.  Knowing is a fragile and individual thing, I can't believe in collective intelligences. I am not hugely keen on measuring students against set criteria but can accept that in most situations that is needed for credit bearing awards.

 I do want to help students develop critical thinking skills; to be aware of the fragility of knowledge and able to challenge their own internal constructions about reality; be able to articulate themselves well in whatever medium they choose; to listen to what others have to say; to listen/read deeply and critically and to say openly what they think without seeing any of it as needing to be set in stone or intransigent. I am sure that can be achieved by many people using many pedagogies and am still struggling as to whether it is possible to, or even worth, defining my own.




Tuesday, 14 July 2015

Thoughts on first day of FOS course

Last night was my first experience of a Twitter shower via the FOS chat, I was using http://tweetchat.com/room/FOSchat  It did not seem to let me add images to my contributions but was handy as the hashtag was added automatically - I often forget to paste in a hashtag when in focused discussions. Looking in my Twitter account I see images were posted and the conversation does make more sense however Tweetchat was an interesting experience.

Earlier in the day I was at the JISC connect more event in Bristol, two names I know via Twitter and was interested to see in person were Sarah Knight and James Clay but I also spotted a fair few names on badges that belong to people I now know are in the FOS community - missed opportunities to say hello.

One of the themes in the Twitter shower was teachers using Twitter for CPD I see that working on at least two levels both of which rely on the 'Gift Society' a concept coined I believe by the founder of Facebook.  One is the use of Twitter as a portal to other resources, often blogs or other professional information sharing sites and sometimes I see links to published journals. The other is professional discourse often between people ho have never met but who are non the less willing and keen to help each other out. The image below shows someone considering the use of some new software (Showbie) then Mr Parkinson and Mark Anderson offering advice.


Twitter in that example is being used to check whether some software is worth trying out, it can take hours to work out how to use new software and sometimes the software is not what we are looking for so this can be a timesaving filter and in this case has added a further option - 'Classroom' OK that might add in more time working out which is best but the whole experience increases the users knowledge so contributes towards their professional development.

Another theme was around Identity and whether to split professional and personal identities. I do that by having two main blogs this one for more professional posts although it is also my learning journal, I also have a blog that is more about family life and have tried others themed on my personal interests.

As far as online identity in my professional world goes another image I wanted to add to the chat is shown in the extract from a blog post on use of audio pasted below. I teach in a fully online world, although I have been in HE since 1998 I have only ever done two traditional lectures from a lecture theatre. The first time I meet 99% of my students is at graduation so conveying a sense of who I am is very different to most teachers who have the classroom or lecture theatre in which most students can construct a sense of who the tutor is via their body language, voice and other real world clues. My courses are predicated on content being of less value than discourse, content is relatively simple honed down to essentials, as the discussions evolve they become the content. For most people text is a very efficient means of hosting asynchronous discussion, it is quick to write and to read and as my students are all in work they need to be able to study at times that are convenient to them, hence text tends to dominate.

One of the first activities I ask students to do when they join the course is to share aspirations, this starts to convey some sense of who they are and who they hope to become:
1. via padlet http://padlet.com/ian_tindal/before_i_graduate
2. via creating a poster, this starts their journey towards using media to handle and present information. http://ii-learning.blogspot.co.uk/search/label/Posters reveal comments to see some of their interactions.

A fair few years ago I started adding podcasts to my online teaching, it was an experiment - could my voice add an extra dimension of inspiration or would the spontaneity help me convey things I would not think of including in text?  The impact on conveying identity was something I had not really looked for. I shy away from video as having my image recorded puts me off balance and I lose the flow of what I want to convey. The image should open full size and clearer if clicked on. The original post is here http://ii-learning.blogspot.co.uk/2013/04/voices-in-machine-reflections-on-use.html

Another theme I though about but couldn't articulate well in the heat of the moment relates to what it means to be ITC proficient:

So what does ICT proficient mean in a rapidly evolving world - ability to constantly adapt?


Q have humans always been doing this? What is new?

What is new is a huge theme, yes humans have been adapting for a long time as have many animals but this very recent evolution to electronic/digital capability and communications faces us with both an attenuation and amplification of complexity in that machines can now relieve us of the burden of vast calculations that would take us months or even years with pen and paper but can be done by well designed software / hardware combinations in seconds. Then there is the amplification of complexity via increasing the social capabilities beyond the located. The first recordings of images and then text in all forms meant information could be accessed by people without the author being present and long after they had ceased to exist. We had to adapt from social learning, through shared experience and conversation held by being with someone, to also having access to the cave or rock surface on which information was recorded, the viewer had to travel to where the information was recorded. Transcribed, then printed, words in books added portability but access was still relatively limited until mass production. Images of newspaper readers on buses and in other public places show newspapers were as attention grabbing as smart devices are today - As a child I remember my gran complaining about how people used to talk more before the war and blaming newspapers, radio and TV for that. Sitting in a train or bus today we appear to have a moved away from public conversation but many people focused on their smart devices are not isolated, much of the time they are absorbed in socially networked conversations with a reach far greater than my gran could ever have achieved or imagined.

So what is new is the diversity of ICT capability and the potential scale of interaction. Anyone with a modern digital device can be a talker or a publisher, generating text and rich media via photos, audio and captured or streamed video or combinations of all. Many people will only do that in their own language but that only scratches the surface as to what is out there. As part of my EdD lit review and a paper I am writing I am looking to find out: 'what is known about this topic' I stumbled across some academic journal resources in Spanish which fortunately I can translate reasonably well, that got me thinking that what we generally find out is just what is known about x topic in languages we understand. Twitter and other social media tends to have translation built in although it is not always perfect it is a lot better than it was a few years ago, we can paste slabs of text from digital documents into Google translate but how often do we bother? I have 1000 words to articulate 'what is known about this topic' in the paper I am writing - that is a bit like presenting an image of one of my fingers as what is known about the being who I am - a tiny almost meaningless insight - what is new is that we have more information that we can cope with so we have to compromise. We have to be careful when reading or writing, we have no chance of knowing what there is to know, more than ever before it is clear that we can not claim breadth of knowledge on a topic or originality in the insights or new contributions we might make to that topic.

One last thing it was suggested we map out digital me - I did that in CMapTools but not yet worked out to share the interactive media version so here is a screen shot without the rollovers and links to media that are on the original. Again it needs to be clicked on to read properly.


Have been monitoring my use of Twitter today to see whether it gets in the way of every day workflow, not a great objective survey thing but I try to keep my behaviour constant with my norms which includes the fairly unusual practice of keeping many windows open for weeks, right now I have 11 browser windows open hosting 52 tabs so its easy to to visit places... as I write this I am having a conversation about PREVENT in Twitter - I hit Twitter while waiting for the phone to be answered and looked at my notifications then timeline spotted / read the prevent discussion. Phone not answered, Grabbed a screen shot of an image for my lit review then started log in to remote desktop so I can use Photoshop to modify the image, while that was opening I had time for 3 responses in Twitter. I had to attach the image to an email to send from my Mac to my remote desktop - 30 secs while it uploaded so another response in Twitter. 30 secs for Photoshop to open so time to read responses to my responses. Then time out for 2 mins to write this. As I am mostly working on a paper for my EdD course today I have found occasional forays into Twitter to be useful diversions, research is concentration heavy and breaks are needed, some people (self included) head to the kitchen for a bit of grazing while mulling things over, hopefully browsing Twitter while ruminating on my research will be a healthier option than grazing.


Weird that having spellchecked this I see that the Google powered Blogger spellchecker does not recognise Google as a word!